Catalan President Artur Mas gave a major speech tonight, which fortunately Liz Castro live-translated on Twitter. To review, here’s where we are now: Catalonia held an informal plebiscite on independence on November 9, which the Constitutional Court had suspended, and 81% of voters supported independence. The Spanish state has refused to negotiate any constitutional revision that would permit a binding referendum on independence, and the state prosecutor has filed criminal charges against Artur Mas and two other cabinet ministers for going ahead with an informal poll. And a new poll (not from CEO, the Catalan government pollster) shows significant majority support for independence among those with an opinion, including support for a unilateral declaration of independence if independentists win the next election.
Since Spain has closed off all legal means to secession, the Catalans are now looking at extralegal means. In tonight’s address, President Mas endorsed “plebiscitary elections” to the Catalan Parliament (previously discussed here). A unified pro-independence list would run in early elections, and if and only if that list obtained a majority of votes and seats, the new Catalan Parliament would declare its intention to secede. Within 18 months, it would set up the institutions of a new state and set the framework for elections to a constituent assembly that would draft a new constitution and declare independence. Anyone who runs on the unified list in the next election would be ineligible to run for the constituent assembly in the subsequent election. Mas himself says he will step down from Parliament at the end of the 18-month term if the plebiscitary election yields a pro-independence majority.
The unified pro-independence list would include members of all pro-independence parties as well as pro-independence members of civil society. Interestingly, Mas’ own party, a federation of a pro-independence party and a much smaller pro-federalism party, looks set to break apart now. The Catalan Republican Left (ERC), the second-largest party in Parliament, wants early elections now and an immediate declaration of independence if secessionists win a majority in that election. They have not ruled out participating in a unified list, however. A small, hard-left, secessionist party, CUP, has ruled out participating in such a list.
There are likely to be several consequences of Mas’ announcement. First, ERC seems to have little choice but to accede to Mas’ terms and timeline. If they refuse, Mas does not need to hold early elections; the independence process stalls. Since ERC are riding high in the polls, they can expect prime placements on the unified list – another reason to come to terms. Second, the reactions from civil society have so far been very positive (for instance, from the Catalan National Assembly). There is likely to be a lot of good feeling among Catalan independentists as a result of Mas’ speech. Third, CUP is likely to see its vote squeezed. Since independence will require a majority vote for the unified list, pro-independence voters will be taking a huge risk by voting for any other party.
Two years ago, I didn’t think the Catalan independence process would get this far, though I did think it possible. The negotiations over a unified list will be difficult, but unless something fundamentally changes Catalan public opinion in the next few months, I now think it likely that a unified list will be formed, and new elections will be held in spring. There will be a massive “tax disobedience” campaign as independentist Catalans pay their taxes to the Catalan government rather than to Spain, and Catalonia will have passed the point of no return.
2 thoughts on “Catalan President Lays Out Road Map to Independence”
I am afraid that you rate the chances of Catalan secession far too highly, despite the tremendously dissappointing turnout (for the Catalan Nationalists) in the unofficial poll.
Barely one in four Catalans with a right to vote bothered to vote for independence, with a resulting near-deafening silence from ERC and the Catalan National Assembly.
Everyone accepts privately that Catalan Independence hasn’t the slightest chance of going through now, but they put on a brave face and pretend that the process is still ongoing.
Mr. Artur Mas’s proposition is deeply upsetting to Mr.Junqueras, leader of ERC, as it puts the onus squarely on him to join the single list headed by Mr. Mas for a plebiscitary election that has every chance of failing in it’s objective.
Mr. Junqueras will probably reply next Tuesday and I doubt very much if he will swallow the poison pill of forming a single list. It would destroy his party and the certain chance of failure makes it deeply unattractive.
The result would be to get Mr. Mas completely off the hook. The fault will be seen as that of ERC; he will feel under no pressure to call an early election, and he will certainly want to hang on for two years more.
Remember that Mr. Rajoy is up for reelection next November and the next President of Spain may be a lot easier to convince.
My betting is still that there will be no autonomous government elections in Catalonia before June at the earliest, and if Mr.Mas has any say in the matter, none at least until after the result of next Novembers general election.
You should take me up on this bet then!