A Path to Fiscal Stability or Symbolic Politics?

The Washington Post reports on some of the details of the Obama administration’s budget proposal, which is to be released next Wednesday. There are several important proposals (the largest of which have appeared before in the negotiations with the Speaker). Although the devil is in the details, a few salient points:

  • $200 billion cut from defense and domestic budgets
  • $400 billion cut from Medicare and other health programs via negotiation over pharmaceuticals and means testing
  • $230 billion (combined cuts and revenues) in Social Security via changes in the formula for calculating cost of living adjustments (from CPI-W to chained CPI)
  • $200 billion from farm subsidies and federal retirement benefits
  • Elimination of a loophole that allows people to simultaneously collect unemployment and disability payments.

All of this (and more) in exchange for $580 billion in new tax revenues largely through ending various tax expenditures. As the Washington Post notes: “The budget is more conservative than Obama’s earlier proposals, which called for $1.6 trillion in new taxes and fewer cuts to health and domestic spending programs.”

If one were serious about achieving long-term fiscal stability, this would appear to be a proposal worth serious consideration. Of course, there will be predictable challenges from the Left and the Right.

  • On the Left, entitlement reform is simply off the table. Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) is quoted as proclaiming: “Millions of working people, seniors, disabled veterans, those who have lost a loved one in combat, and women will be extremely disappointed if President Obama caves into the long-standing Republican effort to cut Social Security.” The same might be said of Medicare. And one can expect the claims that one should not pursue austerity when economic recovery has proven so elusive.
  • On the Right, many in the House GOP will scoff at any more taxation, even if it is accompanied by major concessions on entitlements.  After all, that $580 billion will be stripped from the corporate welfare larded on the oil and gas industry and tax expenditures that currently place no cap on the size of retirement funds (the administration wants to cap tax subsidized retirement accounts at $3 million).

Presidents’ budgets rarely survive the congressional budget process, so the document to be released on Wednesday might be little more that a symbolic gesture that will allow the administration to signal its commitment to fiscal restraint under the assumption that it will be declared DOA before the ink is dry.  But what if the President is serious?

3 thoughts on “A Path to Fiscal Stability or Symbolic Politics?

  1. It’s a good sign from Obama. He’s going out a bit on a limb here. His base will savage him, and he’s also exposing himself to public opinion on entitlements.

  2. A nation cannot have a fiscally balanced budget and,at the same time,a frugal government without real money. Today we use debt receipts as money. Paper receipts substituted for gold and silver is not real money. It never has been or will be. Paper debt money has always failed and has always dragged a nation down into economic catastrophe and eventual political dictatorship. Before a nation can put its economic and fiscal house in order it must first put its monetary house in order. In America this would entail the dismantlement of the Central Banking Federal Reserve System, a return to hard currency, a repeal of the legal tender laws and a repeal of the Income Tax. Unless and until these actions are taken America will wallow in a fiscal wilderness of slow or no growth and eventual national bankruptcy whose paper money currency will be worthless.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s