The Nationalist Politics of the al-Megrahi Release

The release of the terminally ill Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, convicted of involvement in the Lockerbie airplane bombing, is in the news again, due to the oil spill, of all things. The U.S. Congress wants to know whether there was a quid pro quo: whether BP lobbied the Scottish government to release Megrahi so that Libya would conclude a deal allowing BP to drill in its offshore waters. Having followed the Megrahi situation since 2008 because of its relevance to the Nationalist government in Scotland, whose policies and performance I have been following, I have some little expertise on this question. In my view, the posited quid pro quo is the least likely explanation for Megrahi’s release. Consider the following facts:

1) The evidence against Megrahi is less than rock solid. The case against him was built on the testimony of a single witness, later found to be unreliable. Later allegations of prosecutorial misconduct provided a foundation for appeal. In the event, his illness allowed the Scottish government to release him on compassionate grounds instead.

2) Releasing Megrahi allowed the Nationalist government of Scotland, which favors independence for Scotland, to flex its powers on the international stage. Scotland has less autonomy than an American state, but the current government has been trying to make the most of it.

3) Releasing Megrahi allowed the Scottish National Party to burnish its left-wing, peacenik credentials, important given that they have seen an electoral challenge on their left flank from far-left nationalists Solidarity and the Scottish Socialist Party, and given that the SNP’s main electoral rivals are the Labour Party. The SNP has consistently tried to make inroads into the vote-rich Labour constituencies of Scotland’s Central Belt.

4) There was no reason for the SNP or the Scottish government to want to please BP or the British government, who did engage in diplomacy with Libya over the Megrahi issue. If anything, the British Labour government’s desire to release Megrahi would have given the Scottish government some opportunity to twist their tail over the issue and do the reverse.

Unfortunately, media coverage here in the U.S. has done little to elucidate the context behind the decision, which is likely to leave Americans to conclude that skullduggery was involved.


3 thoughts on “The Nationalist Politics of the al-Megrahi Release

  1. There is a very real possibility that the Scottish government released Megrahi on genuine compassionate grounds so that he would drop his appeal against conviction, a conviction which is beginning to look insecure. Such an appeal if successful, would severely undermine the Scottish legal system, which is quite distinct and independent of the English legal system. If it came out that the US administration coreced the German government into releasing two Palestinian bag handlers at Frankfurt airport, people who were arrested on terrorist charges, the international furore could have serious consequences, especially for USA and Britain. Therefore governments in Europe and USA both have a lot to hide and it is surprising US senators are objecting to the release: perhaps thay are simply unaware of what really happened and that the USA was in process of wooing the Syrians at the time and simply had to find a scapegoat elsewhere; Libya.

  2. I’m not sure who the Palestinian bag handlers were that you’re referring to, but on the other point about the Scottish justice system, that does seem like a possible motive as well, although I don’t think there’s much risk that Scotland would lose its legal system over something like this.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s